|
The strip of land between the
Red Sea and the River Nile in Egypt and northern
Sudan is usually referred to as the Eastern Desert
after its location, east of the fertile Nile Valley,
and current arid to hyper-arid climate. The
desertification of the region started with the end
of the Holocene pluvial period (circa
12,000‑7000 years ago) and, as is evident from the
reports of 19th century travellers, continues until
today. The mineral wealth in the area has attracted
intruders from very early times onward, which in
turn have attracted most of the attention of
historians and archaeologists that study the region.
The same is true for the trade routes that connected
the Nile Valley with sub-Saharan
Africa, Arabia Felix, India
and the enigmatic Land of Punt.
Despite environmental
degradation and scholarly neglect, the Eastern
Desert
has its native inhabitants and a history of its own.
Sometimes a hint of these can be gleaned from the
historical sources, for instance in the case of the
Medjay and the Blemmyes, or the archaeological record,
such as pan-graves and Eastern Desert Ware but
information on the indigenous history, culture and
local developments is scarce and incomplete. It is
clear that the connection between the dwellers of the
desert and the dwellers of the Nile Valley must have
been more intricate than indicated by these glimpses
into the past as the pastoral nomads in the Eastern
Desert have always depended on the farmers in the Nile
Valley. The settling of previously mobile
hunter-herder-gatherers in the Nile Valley at the end
of the Holocene pluvial period, on the other hand, may
have been one of the roots of ancient Egyptian
civilization.
|
|
After the publication of
the Netherlands-Flemish Institute in Cairo
(NVIC) volume "Life on the Fringe" (Leiden 1998) and the Cotsen
Institute of Archaeology at UCLA volume "The
Archaeology of Mobility" (Los Angeles 2008) there
remains a clear need for a comprehensive history of
the Eastern
Desert.
One of the anonymous reviewers commenting on the
manuscript of The Archaeology of Mobility
expanded on this need for more and more comprehensive
research of the whole of the Eastern Desert
during all time periods:
At
some point, the Eastern Desert
as a whole should be subjected
to a complete revision of
Pharaonic, Classical and Arabic
sources clarifying the whole
mess. [...] We need
a chart summing up Pharaonic,
Classical and Arabic sources,
not only for the Beja Cushitic
region, but also the northern Eastern
Desert.
Rock art studies should be
included as well, start with the
outdated, but still useful
Winkler, etc.
Apart from logistical
problems, the study of the Eastern Desert is hampered by biases in
the textual sources, by ambiguous ethnographic
parallels and by the low archaeological visibility
of the remains of the desert dwellers. The vast
majority of the historical sources were written by
outsiders who never visited the area. They are
severely prejudiced towards a settled way of life
and express negative attitudes towards mobile
groups that exist until today. Ethnographic and
ethno-archaeological information is limited and
has often been shown to provide only very
incomplete parallels between modern and ancient
mobile groups in the region. Archaeological
evidence on the dwellers of the desert is equally
scarce. The emphasis of the research has been on
the better visible and easier to interpret remains
of the mines, quarries, inscriptions and trade
routes of outsiders temporarily settling in the
desert. Many studies have been biased towards
Pharaonic and Graeco-Roman Egypt, disregarding
Napatan, Meroitic and Nubian sources.
The ephemeral traces of the
desert dwellers appear difficult to recognize and
understand. Indeed, it has only recently been
appreciated that sufficient archaeological remains are
present to allow firm conclusions on the lifestyle and
culture of the dwellers of the Eastern Desert, but
until now research was not focused on their discovery.
During the past decades the anthropological theory on
the relationship between the settled majority and the
mobile minority in the Near East
has developed from the permanent conflict reflected by
the historical sources to the symbiotic relationship
deduced from archaeological and ethno-archaeological
data. Our current terminology, with fixed categories
for mobile and sedentary groups, may not be applicable
to the ancient situation in which such groups appear
even more intertwined than at present. Unfortunately,
these insights come at a time that access into the Eastern Desert (roughly the area
between Aqaba, Cairo,
Khartoum
and Suakin) has become increasingly difficult. A
conference organized by the Cotsen Institute and the
NVIC, to take place in Cairo (Egypt) 25–27 November
2008, aims to use this intermission of fieldwork in
the region to address the problems and possibilities
of the study of the dwellers of the Eastern Desert, as
well as to provide an overview of the current state of
our knowledge.
|
|
|
During a three day meeting in Cairo
the above issues will be discussed. This meeting
will include the presentation of papers and ample
time for discussion between participants, in the
presence of a small audience. Contributions on the
following main topics are expected:
Theory and methodology in the
historical, archaeological and anthropological
study of mobile people. The
focus is on the Eastern Desert,
in all time periods, but contributions need not
necessarily be limited to this region. What recent
anthropological theories apply to the relation
between mobile and sedentary groups in the area?
What new techniques and approaches (such as Google
Earth, GIS, chemical analyses, geology,
climatology, statistics, etc.) should be
incorporated in our research?
The history of the peoples of
the Eastern Desert. What
information do we currently have from textual and
archaeological sources regarding eastern Egypt and Sudan?
Where do these different data sets agree, where do
they differ and how can this be used as a
heuristic tool? Can this data be collated into a
comprehensive history of the region?
The third and last day of the
conference (Thursday 27 November 2008) will be
filled with interviews and discussions with
representatives of the Ababda, a group of pastoral
nomads living in the Eastern Desert,
facilitated by a questionnaire and a translator.
This will provide a unique opportunity to verify or
elucidate matters that emerged during the
conference. In the afternoon a summary of the
conference will be presented in a public lecture
within the framework of the weekly lecture series
and the annual Cleveringa
Lecture at the NVIC. To
enable the discussant to do so, as well as to aid
the discussion during the conference, participants
will be asked to provide an extensive summary of
their presentation well before the start of the
conference.
The proceedings of the
conference, together with the contributions of invited
authors, will be edited as soon as possible after the
conference and submitted for publication, after
peer-review, with the Cotsen Institute. Publication is
planned in a combined paper and on-line format, which
allows for the inclusion of large data files, videos,
animations, virtual reality reconstructions, etc. UCLA
Digital Library will be requested to guarantee the
preservation of such digital files.
Those interested to partake in this meeting are
invited to convey their intention to participate to
the organizers. Please indicate the title and the
subject of the intended contribution in a short
summary (300–500 words). Presentations
are in English and should not exceed 20 minutes,
leaving 10 minutes for discussion. The
conference will take place 25–27 November 2008
in the Netherlands-Flemish Institute in Cairo
(Zamalek) in the presence of a small audience.
|